About the Campaign
The Campaign for Patient Access was launched by the American College of Cardiology in December 2009 as a national effort to reverse Medicare physician fee schedule cuts that threatened cardiovascular care. The site provided background on the issue, the ACC's legislative and legal response, resources for patients and practices, a newsroom tracking coverage across the country, and ways for supporters to share their stories and support the campaign.
From the Newsroom
Medicare Meltdown: Access to Health Care in "Critical Condition"
A press release warning that cardiology access was in critical condition due to Medicare payment cuts.
Read more
Cardiology Takes Legal Action Against Medicare
The ACC filed suit against HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius over the 2010 Physician Fee Schedule.
Read more
ACC Statement on Health Care Reform
The ACC used the State of the Union address to highlight the need to reverse the Medicare cuts.
Read more
Medicare Patients and Physicians Join Petition Drive
Patients and physicians in Washington, DC joined a petition drive calling on Congress for Medicare reform.
Read moreA young mother’s fight for a second opinion
Elena is a 35-year-old mother of two living in Melbourne. After the birth of her younger child, she experienced recurring breathlessness, chest pounding and severe fatigue. Her general practitioner ordered an electrocardiogram and an echocardiogram, then referred her to a cardiologist. The results offered some reassurance but left questions about monitoring and further testing. Her routine outpatient review was still weeks away.
Her account is a composite of concerns raised by patients, not a diagnosis for any one person. The theme of Patient Story: A Young Mother’s Struggle to Get a Second Opinion on Her Heart Condition captures the difficulty many families face: accepting uncertainty while continuing to seek timely, coordinated care. A second opinion can be responsible and constructive, particularly when symptoms persist, explanations remain incomplete or the proposed follow-up does not appear sufficient.
When one opinion did not feel enough
At her first cardiology review, Elena was told that no immediate danger had been identified and was given a follow-up plan. She accepted it, but the interval between visits felt long when her symptoms returned. The unresolved issue was not whether one doctor had been wrong; it was whether the available evidence could support a clearer explanation and a plan matched to her circumstances.
Waiting also disrupted family life. Elena arranged childcare, changed her working hours and repeatedly questioned whether she should be more active or seek help sooner. Uncertainty became especially difficult to carry as a mother, because every decision seemed to affect her children as well as her own health.
A second cardiologist can confirm an existing diagnosis, recommend different investigations, offer a different treatment plan or identify issues that should be addressed by another specialty. It does not guarantee a preferred answer, but it can replace confusion with clearer information and appropriate next steps.
How cardiac second opinions work in Australia
Australia has no single nationwide pathway labelled “second opinion”. The usual starting point is a general practitioner, who can document the reason for another review and refer Elena to a different cardiologist when a Medicare-referred service is required. Patients may also seek private specialist care without a referral, but the Medicare rebate may not apply and the full consultation fee becomes payable.
Public hospital cardiology clinics provide specialist assessment and treatment without outpatient consultation fees in most instances, although non-urgent waiting periods can be substantial. Private cardiology practices in Melbourne and Sydney often provide earlier appointments, yet Medicare rebates usually fall short of the full fee and bulk-billing is not guaranteed. These differences can influence whether families wait, travel or pay privately for a review.
Useful information should be assembled before an appointment. A general practitioner can request earlier results and correspondence, while patients may also access many documents through My Health Record. New chest pressure, severe breathlessness, collapse or fainting requires urgent assessment through 000 rather than waiting for a routine appointment.
Why patient stories need supporting evidence
Patient accounts reveal where care feels difficult. They show the time spent waiting, the cost of repeated appointments and the emotional burden carried by families. Health systems, however, often measure completed appointments and procedures without capturing every delay, referral loop or out-of-pocket expense between them.
Population-level surveillance offers another lens, though it cannot replace clinical follow-up. Research on pharmacy pregnancy surveillance uses sales of prenatal vitamins as a denominator for pregnancy-related syndromic signals. Such patterns can indicate where public-health investigation may be needed, but they cannot show whether an individual mother received timely cardiac care or had her symptoms taken seriously.
Useful Australian measures include waiting times from referral to specialist review, the interval between a new symptom and reassessment, private consultation costs, rates of rereferral and patient-reported experience. The Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, state health services and Medicare data can provide context when individual accounts are combined with credible measures rather than treated as proof of a particular cause.
Turning personal experience into advocacy
Campaign for Patient Access was launched by the American College of Cardiology to oppose Medicare physician fee schedule cuts that threatened cardiovascular care in the United States. Its central message was that payment policy affects whether patients can obtain timely specialist care. Australia has a different Medicare Benefits Schedule and a distinct public-private funding balance, so the same policy cannot simply be imported; local advocates must connect the concern to Australian waiting times, affordability and access.
Campaign resources can help with that translation. The linked example of patient-led campaign outreach demonstrates how a focused, relationship-led approach can help advocates identify decision-makers and turn individual accounts into specific requests. A clear personal account is often more persuasive than a general complaint because it shows what happened, how long it took and what patients need next.
In Australia, that account can support a submission to a federal MP, a Senate committee, a state health minister or a private insurer. Concerns about waiting times, privacy or billing can also be raised through the relevant health service consumer liaison or complaints process. Public advocacy should protect privacy by removing names, dates of birth and medical record numbers whenever the underlying facts are not required.
A practical route to a clearer cardiac review
Before another review, Elena asked her general practitioner for a written summary of her symptoms, test results, medication and proposed follow-up. She also requested copies of her electrocardiogram, echocardiogram, blood tests and discharge correspondence. That single step gave the second cardiologist a clearer starting point and prevented the consultation from being consumed by repeated history-taking.
| Access route | Typical process | Likely waiting and cost pattern | Best use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Public hospital clinic | GP referral where required, followed by clinical triage and outpatient review | No outpatient consultation fee in most public services, but non-urgent waits can be long | Ongoing assessment and hospital-based investigations |
| Private cardiologist | Direct booking may be possible; a GP referral is usually needed for a Medicare rebate | Consultation and tests may attract fees above the rebate; bulk-billing varies | Earlier review and access to some specialised tests |
| Telehealth review | A referral may be needed, with records supplied and local tests arranged when necessary | Reduces travel, although rebates and interstate requirements vary | Reviewing existing results or discussing a diagnosis |
| Emergency department | Triage determines urgency and clinicians assess immediate symptoms | Public emergency care is generally free for medically necessary treatment | Chest pain, severe breathlessness, collapse or other urgent warning signs |
These routes serve different purposes. An emergency assessment does not guarantee a routine outpatient appointment, while a private review should never delay care for urgent symptoms. The right choice depends on clinical urgency, local availability and what can safely wait.
- Ask the GP to document the request for another cardiology opinion and the specific concerns that remain unresolved.
- Request copies of imaging, test results, discharge summaries and correspondence before the appointment.
- Prepare a short timeline covering symptoms, pregnancy and delivery, medication changes, family history and relevant lifestyle factors.
- Bring written questions about the diagnosis, uncertainty, further tests, treatment options, warning signs and the purpose of follow-up.
- Use 000 for new severe chest pain, significant breathlessness, collapse or other urgent symptoms rather than waiting for a review.
Act now for timely heart care
If Elena’s experience resembles your own, tell the story in a factual and privacy-conscious way. Record dates, symptoms, referrals, test results, waiting periods, out-of-pocket costs and what changed after another review. A concise account can be shared with a general practitioner, cardiologist, health service consumer liaison, insurer or federal representative, helping decision-makers see a problem that otherwise disappears inside aggregate statistics.
Clinicians, practices and advocates can convert these accounts into de-identified case summaries, submissions and evidence about where cardiology access fails. The aim is not to condemn an entire system because of one difficult experience, but to identify preventable delays and demand better communication, shorter pathways and affordable follow-up. Speak clearly, document every barrier and help ensure a young mother’s heart care does not become a prolonged fight for basic reassurance.
Campaign for Patient Access