About the Campaign
The Campaign for Patient Access was launched by the American College of Cardiology in December 2009 as a national effort to reverse Medicare physician fee schedule cuts that threatened cardiovascular care. The site provided background on the issue, the ACC's legislative and legal response, resources for patients and practices, a newsroom tracking coverage across the country, and ways for supporters to share their stories and support the campaign.
From the Newsroom
Medicare Meltdown: Access to Health Care in "Critical Condition"
A press release warning that cardiology access was in critical condition due to Medicare payment cuts.
Read more
Cardiology Takes Legal Action Against Medicare
The ACC filed suit against HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius over the 2010 Physician Fee Schedule.
Read more
ACC Statement on Health Care Reform
The ACC used the State of the Union address to highlight the need to reverse the Medicare cuts.
Read more
Medicare Patients and Physicians Join Petition Drive
Patients and physicians in Washington, DC joined a petition drive calling on Congress for Medicare reform.
Read moreWhy Teaching Hospitals Face Unique Challenges From Medicare Payment Cuts
Teaching hospitals occupy a distinctive place in the health system. They deliver highly complex care, train future clinicians, conduct research and often serve as the final referral point for patients whose needs exceed the capacity of community practices. When Medicare physician payments fall, the financial effect reaches far beyond a standard reduction in revenue.
The pressure is especially visible in cardiovascular medicine, where care may involve advanced imaging, electrophysiology, heart failure management, surgery and long-term monitoring. Although the policy debate described here centres on the United States Medicare Physician Fee Schedule, it carries useful lessons for Australia, where public teaching hospitals, Medicare Benefits Schedule rebates and state-funded services face their own cost pressures.
A Payment Cut Travels Through The Teaching Mission
A community clinic can sometimes respond to a lower fee by adjusting appointment volumes, staffing or service mix. A teaching hospital has far less flexibility. Its budget supports clinical care alongside resident supervision, medical education, research administration, clinical trials and round-the-clock specialist coverage.
The physician payment may apply to a consultation or procedure, yet its consequences can affect the entire institution. A cardiology department may use professional revenue to help sustain clinics that are essential for training or access but operate on narrow margins. If those services become financially unsustainable, the hospital may reduce sessions, delay equipment purchases or shift senior clinicians towards higher-volume activities.
Teaching hospitals also carry responsibilities that are difficult to price through a fee schedule. A trainee may require more time to assess a patient, with a consultant reviewing decisions and accepting clinical responsibility. That process improves safety and develops the workforce, but it can make each encounter more resource-intensive than a straightforward private consultation.
Academic Hospitals Carry A Different Cost Base
Tertiary hospitals treat a greater share of patients with complex disease, multiple conditions and urgent needs. Cardiovascular patients may have diabetes, kidney disease, cancer, frailty or a history of stroke. Their appointments require detailed records, multidisciplinary coordination and careful follow-up, while payment formulas may not fully reflect that workload.
Academic centres must also maintain specialised infrastructure. Catheterisation laboratories, cardiac imaging, intensive care beds and emergency response teams need skilled personnel and expensive equipment, even when daily demand fluctuates. Payment cuts can make it harder to preserve capacity for rare but life-threatening cases.
The Australian comparison is useful here. Hospitals such as the Royal Melbourne Hospital, Westmead Hospital in Sydney and the Royal Brisbane and Women’s Hospital manage complicated referrals from wide catchment areas. Their funding arrangements differ from those in the US, but the operational reality is familiar: a major centre cannot simply stop providing high-cost services when patients have nowhere else to go.
The Specialist Workforce Pipeline Is At Risk
Teaching hospitals are the main training ground for cardiologists, cardiac surgeons, intensivists, nurses and allied health professionals. Financial strain can reduce the number of supervised clinics, protected teaching hours and research opportunities available to trainees. It can also make academic careers less attractive compared with private practice.
This matters because workforce shortages develop gradually. A hospital that postpones recruitment or reduces teaching capacity may not feel the full effect for several years. Later, patients may face longer waits for specialist appointments, fewer local services and greater pressure on emergency departments.
In Australia, the distribution of specialists adds another layer. Doctors and nurses are concentrated in Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth and other major centres, while regional and remote communities depend on visiting services, telehealth and referral pathways. If a teaching hospital cannot support enough trainees, the shortage can reach far beyond its metropolitan campus.
Complex Referrals Make Access More Fragile
Teaching hospitals commonly accept patients who have been turned away by smaller facilities because they need advanced diagnostics, specialist teams or intensive monitoring. This role makes them a safety net for the entire region. A payment reduction can therefore affect patients who never receive a bill from the teaching hospital themselves.
Cardiology illustrates the problem clearly. A patient from a regional town may travel several hours for an electrophysiology review or a heart failure assessment. If a clinic closes or appointment capacity falls, the alternative may be a long wait, repeated emergency presentations or an expensive trip to a private provider.
| Pressure from lower physician payments | Likely effect in a teaching hospital | Consequence for patients |
|---|---|---|
| Reduced professional revenue | Fewer clinic sessions or slower recruitment | Longer waits for specialist care |
| Higher supervision requirements | Less time for teaching and trainee support | A weaker future workforce |
| Complex case mix | Greater financial loss on time-intensive visits | Pressure to prioritise simpler cases |
| Fixed infrastructure costs | Delayed equipment upgrades and maintenance | Less capacity for advanced treatment |
| Regional referral dependence | More strain on transport and outreach services | Greater geographic inequality |
Australian patients often understand this through practical experience: a “bulk billed” service may be available in one suburb but not another, and a public hospital referral can involve weeks of waiting or a long journey. Medicare coverage does not remove the cost of travel, time away from work or accommodation near a tertiary centre.
Payment Policy Shapes Clinical Choices
When reimbursement does not keep pace with the cost of care, hospitals may review which services they can continue to provide. This does not necessarily mean clinicians abandon patients. More often, access changes gradually through fewer appointment slots, narrower referral criteria, reduced outreach or a greater reliance on primary care.
Such decisions can unintentionally favour patients who are easier to treat. A straightforward follow-up visit may be more financially viable than a complex consultation involving several conditions, an interpreter, a carer or extensive record review. Yet the patients who need the most clinical attention are often those least able to navigate fragmented services.
The distinction between hospital funding and physician payment is important in Australia. Public hospitals are largely financed through state and territory systems, while Medicare rebates influence medical services delivered in hospitals, private rooms and community practices. A pressure in one part of the system can still shift costs elsewhere, such as emergency departments, general practices or patients paying a gap fee.
A Fairer Response Must Recognise Value
Payment reform should account for the full role of teaching hospitals rather than treating every consultation as an interchangeable transaction. Risk adjustment, complexity measures and support for graduate medical education can help align funding with the work these centres perform.
Policy makers should also examine the interaction between professional fees, hospital budgets and research funding. A cut that appears modest at the national level may be severe for a department already balancing workforce shortages, rising wages and expensive technology. Transparent reporting can show which services are threatened and which communities are most exposed.
For Australian health leaders, the lesson is to assess access across the whole patient journey. A Medicare rebate, state hospital allocation or private insurance payment may look adequate in isolation, while the combined system still leaves patients facing delays. Data from metropolitan teaching hospitals should be considered alongside regional travel times, bulk-billing availability and the capacity of smaller hospitals.
Priorities For Protecting Specialist Access
Hospitals, professional bodies, patient advocates and policy makers can focus on practical safeguards:
- Protect funding for supervised training, including consultant teaching time and clinical placements.
- Measure payment adequacy against patient complexity, appointment duration and care coordination.
- Preserve outreach cardiology, telehealth and referral support for regional and remote communities.
- Publish the likely effects of fee changes on waiting lists, staffing, equipment and service availability.
- Include patient stories when assessing access, particularly experiences involving travel, delays and out-of-pocket costs.
- Align Medicare, hospital funding and research support so that one budget decision does not weaken another part of care.
The policy debate should remain grounded in what patients experience when a service disappears or becomes harder to reach. Cardiovascular care depends on timely assessment, continuity and specialist expertise; postponing treatment can turn a manageable condition into an emergency.
Patients and clinicians can help protect that access by sharing credible examples with professional associations, hospital boards, elected representatives and health departments. In the United States, that means supporting a payment system that recognises the role of teaching hospitals in Medicare-funded care. In Australia, it means speaking up for sustainable public hospitals, fair Medicare rebates and a specialist workforce available beyond the capital cities. Health policy is shaped by evidence, but personal accounts show decision-makers what those policies mean in real lives.
Campaign for Patient Access