About the Campaign
The Campaign for Patient Access was launched by the American College of Cardiology in December 2009 as a national effort to reverse Medicare physician fee schedule cuts that threatened cardiovascular care. The site provided background on the issue, the ACC's legislative and legal response, resources for patients and practices, a newsroom tracking coverage across the country, and ways for supporters to share their stories and support the campaign.
From the Newsroom
Medicare Meltdown: Access to Health Care in "Critical Condition"
A press release warning that cardiology access was in critical condition due to Medicare payment cuts.
Read more
Cardiology Takes Legal Action Against Medicare
The ACC filed suit against HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius over the 2010 Physician Fee Schedule.
Read more
ACC Statement on Health Care Reform
The ACC used the State of the Union address to highlight the need to reverse the Medicare cuts.
Read more
Medicare Patients and Physicians Join Petition Drive
Patients and physicians in Washington, DC joined a petition drive calling on Congress for Medicare reform.
Read moreMedicare Payment Reform and the Future of Specialty Care
Medicare payment policy has changed repeatedly since the program began in 1965. Each reform attempted to address a different concern: rising federal spending, inconsistent payment across physicians, unnecessary services, or the need to reward better outcomes. For specialists, however, these changes have also affected staffing, technology investment, appointment availability, and the ability to maintain services in underserved communities.
The history of Medicare payment reform is therefore more than a record of formulas and legislation. It is a history of how public policy has shaped clinical practice. Cardiologists, oncologists, surgeons, radiologists, neurologists, and other specialists have had to adapt to payment systems that often value time, procedures, evaluation, and care coordination differently.
Understanding that history helps explain why physician organizations and patient advocates continue to focus on Medicare reimbursement. Payment decisions influence whether practices can recruit clinicians, offer advanced services, and provide timely care to older adults and people with complex medical needs.
From Hospital Insurance To Physician Fee Schedules
When Medicare was created, physician services were generally reimbursed through a system based on customary charges. Physicians submitted charges, and Medicare paid according to prevailing rates in a local area. This approach was relatively flexible, but it gave the program limited control over spending. Fees could vary significantly for similar services, and payment levels did not always reflect the resources required to deliver care.
Congress gradually moved toward a more structured approach. The Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1989 established the framework for a national physician payment system based on a resource-based relative value scale, commonly called RBRVS. The system divided each service into work, practice expense, and professional liability components. These values were multiplied by a conversion factor and adjusted for geographic differences.
The Medicare Physician Fee Schedule took effect in 1992. Its central goal was to create a more consistent relationship between the resources used for different services. It also sought to correct perceived imbalances between procedural and cognitive care. For specialists, the change meant that payment would increasingly depend on nationally determined relative values rather than local charge patterns.
The Shift To Resource-Based Valuation
RBRVS gave policymakers a common language for comparing services, but it did not eliminate disagreements about valuation. The work involved in a complex procedure may be easier to quantify than the time required to evaluate a patient with several interacting conditions. Specialists have often argued that payment formulas can undervalue cognitive effort, care planning, follow-up, and the use of highly trained teams.
Practice expense calculations have also become increasingly important. A specialty practice may need expensive imaging equipment, clinical laboratories, surgical facilities, information technology, regulatory support, and specialized personnel. Payment reductions that appear modest at the individual service level can have a substantial effect when applied across a practice with high fixed costs.
The fee schedule is updated through an administrative process involving the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, the American Medical Association’s Relative Value Scale Update Committee, and public comment. Those decisions can change the relative value of services, but they do not always keep pace with inflation, labor expenses, or the cost of maintaining modern clinical infrastructure.
Why Sustainable Growth Failed Specialists
The Balanced Budget Act of 1997 introduced the Sustainable Growth Rate, or SGR, to control Medicare spending on physician services. The formula tied updates in physician payment to economic growth and overall Medicare spending. If spending exceeded the target, future payment updates were supposed to decline.
In practice, the SGR produced a series of scheduled reductions that Congress repeatedly postponed. These temporary legislative fixes became known as the doc fix. The recurring uncertainty made it difficult for specialists to plan investments, negotiate employment arrangements, or predict the financial stability of community practices. A reduction that was avoided one year could reappear as a larger projected cut the next.
The SGR was especially disruptive because it treated aggregate spending as the primary signal, rather than distinguishing between appropriate and inappropriate care. A cardiology practice that delivered medically necessary services could face a payment reduction because of spending trends elsewhere in the Medicare system. In 2015, Congress replaced the SGR with the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act, known as MACRA.
| Reform Era | Main Payment Approach | Effect On Specialists |
|---|---|---|
| 1965–1980s | Customary and prevailing charges | Broad variation in fees and limited spending control |
| 1992 onward | Resource-based relative values and a national fee schedule | Greater consistency, with continuing disputes over service valuation |
| 1997–2015 | Sustainable Growth Rate | Repeated threatened cuts and significant payment uncertainty |
| 2015 onward | MACRA, MIPS, and advanced alternative payment models | Greater emphasis on quality, reporting, technology, and performance |
| Recent years | Annual fee schedule adjustments and targeted policy changes | Ongoing pressure from inflation, workforce costs, and budget constraints |
MACRA And The Move Toward Value
MACRA created two major paths for clinicians: the Merit-based Incentive Payment System, or MIPS, and advanced alternative payment models. MIPS combines quality, cost, improvement activities, and promoting interoperability into a performance score that can affect Medicare payments. Alternative payment models seek to move away from paying separately for every service by linking reimbursement to defined populations, episodes, or clinical outcomes.
The law was intended to provide a more stable replacement for the SGR while encouraging higher-quality, more coordinated care. It also consolidated several earlier reporting programs, including the Physician Quality Reporting System and the Value Modifier. For specialists, the transition brought new responsibilities involving data collection, electronic health records, quality measurement, and documentation.
Value-based payment has produced useful incentives, particularly when measures reflect meaningful clinical outcomes. Yet specialists have raised concerns about measures that are difficult to influence, depend on patient factors, or impose high reporting costs. A small practice may spend significant time meeting program requirements without having the staff or technology available to manage complex performance data.
How Reform Changes Specialty Practice
Medicare reimbursement affects far more than a physician’s personal income. It shapes whether a practice can hire nurses, physician assistants, technicians, schedulers, and billing specialists. It also influences the availability of diagnostic testing, hospital coverage, telehealth, clinical trials, and services that require costly equipment.
Specialty care often involves a mix of evaluation, procedures, monitoring, and long-term management. A patient with cardiovascular disease, for example, may need imaging, medication adjustment, preventive counseling, rhythm monitoring, and coordination with primary care. If the payment system rewards one part of that pathway but undervalues the rest, practices may struggle to provide comprehensive care.
Payment pressure can be particularly serious in rural and underserved areas. Smaller communities may have too few specialists to absorb a reduction in Medicare revenue. Physicians may limit new Medicare patients, reduce office hours, or relocate services to larger markets. Patients can then face longer travel distances and delays in diagnosis or treatment.
The Connection Between Payment And Access
The debate over Medicare physician payment is ultimately a debate about access. A payment cut may be presented as a federal budget adjustment, but its practical effects can include postponed appointments, reduced service lines, fewer available specialists, and less capacity for emergency consultation. These effects are not always immediate, and they can vary by specialty and region.
Annual updates also matter because medical practices face rising expenses even when the fee schedule remains flat. Wages, malpractice coverage, rent, supplies, technology, and compliance costs continue to change. When reimbursement fails to keep pace, a practice may need to compensate through volume, consolidation, reduced staffing, or limits on less profitable services.
Patient and physician advocacy can bring these consequences into the policy discussion. Personal accounts from patients who struggled to obtain specialty care, along with information from practices about operating costs and workforce needs, can help lawmakers understand how payment formulas translate into real-world outcomes.
Building A More Durable Payment Policy
Future reforms will need to balance fiscal responsibility with the operational realities of specialty medicine. A durable system should recognize the value of evaluation and management, complex decision-making, care coordination, emergency availability, and the infrastructure required for advanced procedures. It should also avoid placing disproportionate administrative demands on small practices.
Useful policy priorities include:
- Providing predictable annual updates that account for inflation and clinical workforce costs
- Testing quality measures for clinical relevance, reliability, and fairness before linking them to payment
- Reducing duplicative reporting and simplifying requirements for smaller practices
- Supporting specialty care in rural, underserved, and safety-net communities
- Evaluating access, workforce capacity, and patient outcomes alongside federal spending
Payment reform should also allow room for different models of care. A large integrated health system may be able to participate in an advanced alternative payment model, while an independent cardiology or oncology practice may need a simpler structure. Flexibility can encourage innovation without making participation dependent on substantial administrative resources.
The Campaign for Patient Access reflects the continuing role of public engagement in this process. Patients, physicians, and caregivers can document how Medicare policies affect appointments, treatment options, and local services. Sharing credible stories with professional organizations, policymakers, and the public helps connect technical payment debates with the people those policies are meant to serve.
Medicare payment reform will continue to evolve as the program responds to demographic change, new treatments, workforce shortages, and budget pressures. Preserving access to specialty care requires attention to both the numbers in a payment formula and the consequences beyond it. Patients and physicians can support that effort by sharing their experiences, staying informed about policy proposals, and speaking up for reimbursement decisions that sustain high-quality care.
Campaign for Patient Access