Warm-toned photograph of a stethoscope resting on a wooden desk beside medical charts, conveying a serious healthcare setting

A national public affairs campaign launched by the American College of Cardiology in December 2009 to oppose Medicare physician fee schedule cuts affecting cardiology patients and practices.

About the Campaign

The Campaign for Patient Access was launched by the American College of Cardiology in December 2009 as a national effort to reverse Medicare physician fee schedule cuts that threatened cardiovascular care. The site provided background on the issue, the ACC's legislative and legal response, resources for patients and practices, a newsroom tracking coverage across the country, and ways for supporters to share their stories and support the campaign.

From the Newsroom

Capitol building dome against a pale sky, conveying federal policy and legislative action
April 30, 2010

Medicare Meltdown: Access to Health Care in "Critical Condition"

A press release warning that cardiology access was in critical condition due to Medicare payment cuts.

Read more
Gavel on a dark wooden bench in a courtroom setting, suggesting legal proceedings
December 29, 2009

Cardiology Takes Legal Action Against Medicare

The ACC filed suit against HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius over the 2010 Physician Fee Schedule.

Read more
A stack of newspapers with a muted gray and off-white palette, suggesting breaking health policy news
January 12, 2010

ACC Statement on Health Care Reform

The ACC used the State of the Union address to highlight the need to reverse the Medicare cuts.

Read more
A wide shot of a diverse group of healthcare professionals and advocates gathered around a conference table, deep in discussion
April 12, 2010

Medicare Patients and Physicians Join Petition Drive

Patients and physicians in Washington, DC joined a petition drive calling on Congress for Medicare reform.

Read more

Why Medicare payment reform matters for lasting patient access

Medicare’s physician payment system was built for a different era of medicine. It still relies heavily on a fee schedule that assigns values to individual services, even though modern cardiovascular care depends on coordination, prevention, technology, team-based work, and long-term management. The result is a structure that often rewards volume while underfunding the time and infrastructure required to keep patients healthy.

Payment updates have also struggled to keep pace with inflation, staffing costs, technology investments, and the growing complexity of older patients. When reimbursement fails to reflect those realities, medical practices face difficult choices: limit appointments, reduce services, delay equipment upgrades, or shift resources away from patients who need extensive care.

Comprehensive reform should therefore be viewed as an access issue, a quality issue, and a workforce issue. A reliable Medicare payment model can help physicians sustain independent practices, support rural and underserved communities, and deliver timely specialty care without placing the full burden on patients.

Why the current fee schedule falls short

The Medicare Physician Fee Schedule is designed around relative values for clinical services. Those values are converted into payment amounts through a formula that includes a conversion factor, geographic adjustments, and annual policy decisions. Although the system appears technical and precise, its underlying assumptions can lag behind the actual cost of delivering care.

Many services require substantial work that is difficult to capture in a single billing code. Reviewing test results, coordinating with other clinicians, managing medications, responding to patient concerns, and monitoring chronic disease may consume significant time without generating a corresponding payment. Cardiovascular care illustrates the problem because a patient’s outcome often depends on consistent follow-up rather than one isolated procedure.

Annual reductions intensify this pressure. When operating costs rise while Medicare reimbursement stagnates or declines, practices must absorb the gap. Large health systems may have reserves or alternative revenue streams, but smaller practices often have fewer options. That imbalance can accelerate consolidation and reduce the number of locations where beneficiaries can receive care.

How payment instability affects patient access

Payment policy is often discussed as a matter for physicians, administrators, and lawmakers. In practice, its effects reach patients quickly. A cardiology practice facing unsustainable reimbursement may stop accepting new Medicare patients, shorten appointment availability, or refer complex cases elsewhere. Patients in communities with few specialists have the most difficulty replacing lost capacity.

Access problems can also appear gradually. A practice may postpone hiring a nurse, care coordinator, or technician. It may delay replacing diagnostic equipment or reduce time devoted to preventive counseling. Each decision can seem manageable in isolation, yet the combined effect is a thinner care system with longer waits and fewer opportunities to identify problems early.

Patients with cardiovascular disease are especially vulnerable to gaps in continuity. Missed follow-up, delayed testing, or difficulty obtaining medication advice can contribute to avoidable emergency visits and hospitalizations. A payment policy that focuses narrowly on the price of a visit may overlook the far greater cost of fragmented care.

What comprehensive reform should address

A durable solution must go beyond changing a single annual update. It should examine how Medicare values services, measures quality, supports innovation, and distributes resources among different communities. Reform should also provide predictable financial signals so practices can plan staffing, technology, and patient services over several years rather than reacting to short-term cuts.

Payment approach Primary strength Common limitation Reform opportunity
Fee-for-service Pays for defined services and remains familiar Can undervalue coordination and prevention Update values and recognize cognitive and care-management work
Merit-based incentives Links some payment to quality measures Reporting burden and uneven measures Simplify metrics and focus on outcomes patients can understand
Bundled payments Encourages coordination around an episode of care May be difficult for complex, multi-condition patients Adjust for risk and include specialty-specific needs
Capitated or prospective payments Supports planning and ongoing management Can create concern about under-treatment Pair with strong access, quality, and patient-protection standards
Hybrid models Balances stability with accountability Requires careful design and oversight Combine reliable base payments with meaningful outcome incentives

A reformed system should adequately value evaluation and management services, chronic disease monitoring, care coordination, and digital communication when those activities improve outcomes. It should also account for clinical complexity so physicians are not penalized for treating patients with multiple conditions, limited transportation, or serious social needs.

Payment reform must preserve a role for innovation without forcing every practice into the same model. A rural clinic, an urban safety-net practice, and a large multispecialty group may need different pathways. Common standards for access and quality can coexist with flexible methods for reaching them.

Moving beyond short-term payment patches

Temporary fixes can prevent immediate disruption, but they do not create a dependable foundation for Medicare beneficiaries or clinicians. Repeated uncertainty makes it harder for practices to sign leases, invest in equipment, recruit physicians, or build care-management programs. It also consumes time that could be spent improving patient services.

A multi-year update framework would offer greater stability. Such a framework could use an inflation-sensitive component, review the costs of running different types of practices, and establish targeted adjustments for specialties that face unusual workforce or technology demands. Periodic evaluations could ensure that payments remain aligned with clinical evidence and patient needs.

Legislators and regulators should also examine the interaction between Medicare rates and other parts of the healthcare market. When public payment falls substantially below the cost of care, commercial negotiations and hospital employment may become the only ways for physicians to maintain financial viability. That can reduce competition and leave patients with fewer independent choices.

Aligning incentives with better cardiovascular care

Quality measurement can improve care when it is clinically meaningful and used responsibly. However, an excessive number of measures can turn quality improvement into a documentation exercise. Physicians may spend time entering data that has little connection to outcomes while receiving limited support for changes that genuinely help patients.

A better approach would emphasize a focused set of measures, such as timely follow-up, medication adherence support, control of major risk factors, avoidable hospitalization rates, and patient-reported access. Measures should be risk-adjusted and tested for unintended consequences. Practices serving medically complex or disadvantaged populations should not be punished for taking on patients who need more help.

Value-based care can succeed when clinicians have the resources to provide it. That means funding care coordinators, interoperable health information, remote monitoring when appropriate, and communication between primary care, specialists, hospitals, and community services. Reimbursement should recognize these functions rather than treating them as invisible overhead.

Patients and physicians can help bring practical experience into the policy debate. The patient access campaign offers a useful example of advocacy focused on how Medicare payment decisions affect real practices and the people who depend on them. Personal accounts can show policymakers what statistics may miss: delayed appointments, closed offices, and difficult choices about who can be served.

Building a fairer and more resilient system

Equity should be a central test of Medicare payment reform. A national schedule does not automatically produce equal access because the cost of recruiting clinicians, maintaining facilities, and serving patients varies widely. Geographic adjustments, rural incentives, and support for underserved areas should reflect actual barriers rather than assume that every community has the same resources.

Reform should also protect patients from abrupt disruptions. When a practice changes ownership, exits a network, or reduces Medicare participation, beneficiaries need timely notice and help finding alternative care. Public reporting on appointment availability, participation, and service closures could make access trends easier to identify before they become crises.

Physician participation is essential to workable policy. Clinicians should have meaningful opportunities to review proposed changes, explain operational effects, and help design measures. Patients deserve a similar voice, especially those living with chronic cardiovascular conditions and those who face transportation, language, disability, or financial barriers.

Practical priorities for policymakers and advocates

A comprehensive agenda can begin with several concrete actions:

  • Establish predictable, multi-year Medicare payment updates that reflect inflation and the cost of maintaining clinical capacity.
  • Revalue evaluation, management, prevention, care coordination, and chronic disease services alongside procedures.
  • Simplify quality reporting and use a smaller set of outcome-focused, risk-adjusted measures.
  • Provide targeted support for rural, safety-net, and independent practices that serve vulnerable Medicare beneficiaries.
  • Encourage patient and physician testimony when payment changes threaten local access to specialty care.

These priorities are compatible with accountability. Physicians should be expected to deliver safe, effective care, while Medicare should provide a payment environment that makes those expectations achievable. A system that demands coordination, access, and prevention must finance the people and infrastructure required to provide them.

Reform should be judged by practical results: whether patients can obtain timely appointments, whether clinicians can remain in the communities they serve, and whether practices can invest in better care. Those standards are more meaningful than a payment formula that appears stable on paper while steadily weakening access in daily life.

Medicare beneficiaries, physicians, professional organizations, and community leaders can help move this issue from annual debate to sustained action. Sharing local experiences, contacting policymakers, and supporting evidence-based proposals can make the consequences of payment decisions visible. Protecting access to cardiovascular care requires a payment system designed for the medicine patients receive today, with the flexibility and stability needed for tomorrow.

A close-up of a handwritten letter on paper beside a pen, warm natural light, soft cream and muted gray tones

Share Your Story

Tell us how Medicare cuts affected access to cardiovascular care. Stories could be reviewed and submitted to local news outlets as part of the campaign's outreach.