Warm-toned photograph of a stethoscope resting on a wooden desk beside medical charts, conveying a serious healthcare setting

A national public affairs campaign launched by the American College of Cardiology in December 2009 to oppose Medicare physician fee schedule cuts affecting cardiology patients and practices.

About the Campaign

The Campaign for Patient Access was launched by the American College of Cardiology in December 2009 as a national effort to reverse Medicare physician fee schedule cuts that threatened cardiovascular care. The site provided background on the issue, the ACC's legislative and legal response, resources for patients and practices, a newsroom tracking coverage across the country, and ways for supporters to share their stories and support the campaign.

From the Newsroom

Capitol building dome against a pale sky, conveying federal policy and legislative action
April 30, 2010

Medicare Meltdown: Access to Health Care in "Critical Condition"

A press release warning that cardiology access was in critical condition due to Medicare payment cuts.

Read more
Gavel on a dark wooden bench in a courtroom setting, suggesting legal proceedings
December 29, 2009

Cardiology Takes Legal Action Against Medicare

The ACC filed suit against HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius over the 2010 Physician Fee Schedule.

Read more
A stack of newspapers with a muted gray and off-white palette, suggesting breaking health policy news
January 12, 2010

ACC Statement on Health Care Reform

The ACC used the State of the Union address to highlight the need to reverse the Medicare cuts.

Read more
A wide shot of a diverse group of healthcare professionals and advocates gathered around a conference table, deep in discussion
April 12, 2010

Medicare Patients and Physicians Join Petition Drive

Patients and physicians in Washington, DC joined a petition drive calling on Congress for Medicare reform.

Read more

Why MACRA Matters for Medicare Patients and Clinicians

The Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act reshaped how Medicare pays physicians and how policymakers evaluate the quality of care. Enacted in 2015, MACRA replaced the much-criticized Sustainable Growth Rate formula with a framework intended to reward value, improve outcomes, and give medical practices a more predictable path for participating in Medicare.

The law matters to patients because payment policy affects the availability of services. When reimbursement fails to keep pace with staffing, technology, compliance, and clinical demands, practices may limit Medicare appointments, delay investments, or struggle to maintain specialty programs. Cardiovascular care is especially sensitive to these pressures because it often requires advanced equipment, coordinated follow-up, and highly trained teams.

For physicians, MACRA created new reporting responsibilities and tied portions of Medicare reimbursement to performance. Its importance therefore reaches beyond a single payment update. It influences practice strategy, health information technology, care coordination, and the long-term ability of patients to find and keep physicians who accept Medicare.

Replacing An Unstable Payment Formula

Before MACRA, Medicare physician payments were governed by the Sustainable Growth Rate system. The formula was designed to control spending, but it repeatedly produced scheduled reductions that Congress postponed through short-term legislative fixes. This pattern created uncertainty for clinicians and made it difficult for practices to plan budgets, hire staff, or invest in patient services.

MACRA repealed the SGR and established a more structured approach to Medicare physician reimbursement. Rather than relying on repeated emergency patches, the law introduced scheduled payment updates and a framework that could recognize quality, efficiency, and participation in alternative payment models.

The change did not eliminate payment disputes. Medicare payment rates continue to be shaped by annual rules, inflationary pressures, congressional action, and the costs of running a modern practice. Still, replacing the SGR gave policymakers and medical professionals a clearer foundation for discussing payment reform.

Linking Payment With Quality And Value

A central part of MACRA is the Quality Payment Program, which includes the Merit-based Incentive Payment System and Advanced Alternative Payment Models. MIPS evaluates eligible clinicians through categories such as quality, cost, improvement activities, and promoting interoperability. Advanced APMs generally involve greater financial risk and a more coordinated approach to care.

The goal is to move Medicare away from paying primarily for the volume of services. A value-based payment system may encourage preventive care, better transitions between clinicians, medication management, and closer attention to outcomes. In cardiology, these priorities can support efforts to reduce avoidable hospitalizations and help patients manage chronic conditions such as heart failure and coronary artery disease.

The design of these programs requires care. Measures must reflect meaningful clinical work rather than encourage documentation for its own sake. They also need to account for patient complexity, social needs, small-practice resources, and the different ways specialties deliver care. A poorly designed measure can penalize a physician who serves a medically complex population or works in an underserved community.

Supporting Access To Specialty Care

The importance of MACRA becomes especially visible when reimbursement pressures affect access. Cardiovascular patients may need diagnostic testing, procedures, rehabilitation, medication adjustments, and regular monitoring. These services depend on an interconnected workforce that includes physicians, nurses, technicians, pharmacists, and administrative staff.

If payment reductions outpace the cost of care, a practice may face difficult choices. It might reduce appointment capacity, defer equipment purchases, consolidate with a larger organization, or stop accepting new Medicare patients. Rural and independent practices can be particularly vulnerable because they often operate with fewer financial reserves and have limited access to economies of scale.

MACRA was intended to support sustainable physician participation in Medicare, but its success must be judged by what patients experience. A payment model that rewards a narrow set of metrics while weakening the underlying practice infrastructure can undermine access. Policymakers should therefore consider workforce stability, geographic availability, appointment wait times, and continuity of care alongside formal quality scores.

How The Law Affects Practices

MACRA gives practices incentives to collect reliable clinical data and examine how care is delivered. That work can reveal gaps in preventive services, follow-up, medication adherence, and communication among providers. When used well, performance data can help clinicians identify patients who need additional support rather than simply serve as a compliance exercise.

At the same time, reporting can impose substantial costs. Smaller practices may need new software, consultants, dedicated staff, or outside partners to meet program requirements. Physicians also have to reconcile Medicare rules with commercial payer contracts, state regulations, cybersecurity needs, and the everyday demands of patient care.

The following comparison shows how MACRA’s major elements connect policy objectives with practical effects:

MACRA Element Policy Purpose Potential Effect On Patients And Practices
Repeal of the SGR Replace recurring payment crises with a more stable framework Improves planning, though annual payment decisions still create uncertainty
MIPS Adjust payment according to reported performance Encourages measurement but can increase administrative work
Advanced APMs Promote coordinated care and shared accountability May support better outcomes when models fit the specialty and patient population
Quality and cost measures Focus attention on outcomes and resource use Can guide improvement when measures are clinically relevant and risk-adjusted
CHIP reauthorization Continue federal support for children’s health coverage Helps eligible children maintain access to preventive and essential care
Technical assistance and reporting tools Help clinicians participate in new payment programs May reduce burden, especially for smaller or rural practices

Protecting Fairness In Measurement

A fair Medicare value-based system must recognize that physicians do not control every factor affecting an outcome. Transportation barriers, food insecurity, health literacy, medication costs, and limited access to primary care can all influence a patient’s health. Risk adjustment and careful measure selection are essential if clinicians serving complex populations are to be evaluated responsibly.

Meaningful measurement also requires clinical relevance. A metric should reflect something physicians can influence and patients value. For cardiovascular care, measures may address blood pressure control, appropriate use of preventive therapies, follow-up after hospitalization, or management of chronic disease. Yet a score should complement professional judgment, not replace it.

Patients and clinicians have a role in communicating when payment rules produce unintended consequences. Personal accounts can show how a policy affects appointment availability, care coordination, and the ability to maintain a local specialty practice. Policy responses may include regulatory comments, congressional outreach, and legal action when payment decisions raise serious concerns about access or statutory obligations.

Preserving CHIP And Broader Coverage

The “CHIP” portion of MACRA is also significant. The Children’s Health Insurance Program provides coverage for children in families who may earn too much to qualify for Medicaid but still face difficulty affording private insurance. Reauthorizing CHIP helped preserve a major source of pediatric coverage and reduced the risk that eligible children would experience gaps in preventive and acute care.

Children’s coverage has long-term implications for public health. Regular checkups, immunizations, screenings, and early treatment can identify problems before they become more severe and expensive. Continuous insurance coverage also gives families greater confidence that they can seek care when symptoms arise.

Although physician payment policy and children’s coverage address different populations, they share a central principle: access depends on stable public policy. Coverage is meaningful only when patients can find participating clinicians, obtain timely appointments, and receive services in their communities. MACRA connects these concerns within a broader federal effort to sustain healthcare delivery.

Priorities For A Sustainable Medicare Program

The law’s framework should continue to evolve as policymakers assess performance and listen to those affected. Future reforms can preserve the shift toward value while reducing unnecessary reporting, improving technical support, and ensuring that payment updates reflect the actual cost of delivering care.

Important priorities include:

  • Keep Medicare payment policy predictable enough for practices to plan staffing, equipment, and services.
  • Use clinically meaningful measures that emphasize outcomes patients can understand and value.
  • Protect small, rural, and safety-net practices from disproportionate administrative and financial burdens.
  • Account for medical complexity and social barriers when evaluating physician performance.
  • Pair value-based incentives with strong oversight of access, network participation, and appointment availability.

These priorities are especially important for specialties that require costly infrastructure and ongoing coordination. A cardiology practice may deliver excellent care yet still face financial strain if payment formulas overlook the resources needed for imaging, monitoring, care teams, and rapid follow-up.

Making Reform Work For Patients

The importance of MACRA ultimately depends on whether it strengthens the relationship between payment policy and patient care. A well-designed program should encourage better outcomes without making it harder for Medicare beneficiaries to see qualified physicians. It should support innovation while respecting the realities of different specialties, communities, and practice sizes.

Patients can contribute by sharing experiences with delayed appointments, changes in local services, or successful care coordination. Physicians and practice leaders can document the operational effects of payment rules and participate in public policy discussions. Professional organizations, lawmakers, and regulators need that evidence when evaluating whether a payment change is improving value or weakening access.

MACRA created an important foundation for replacing unstable physician payment policy with a more accountable system. Its promise will be fulfilled only through continued attention to fair measurement, adequate reimbursement, administrative practicality, and dependable access to care. Patients and clinicians can help keep those goals visible by learning how Medicare payment decisions affect their communities and by supporting policies that sustain high-quality services.

A close-up of a handwritten letter on paper beside a pen, warm natural light, soft cream and muted gray tones

Share Your Story

Tell us how Medicare cuts affected access to cardiovascular care. Stories could be reviewed and submitted to local news outlets as part of the campaign's outreach.