About the Campaign
The Campaign for Patient Access was launched by the American College of Cardiology in December 2009 as a national effort to reverse Medicare physician fee schedule cuts that threatened cardiovascular care. The site provided background on the issue, the ACC's legislative and legal response, resources for patients and practices, a newsroom tracking coverage across the country, and ways for supporters to share their stories and support the campaign.
From the Newsroom
Medicare Meltdown: Access to Health Care in "Critical Condition"
A press release warning that cardiology access was in critical condition due to Medicare payment cuts.
Read more
Cardiology Takes Legal Action Against Medicare
The ACC filed suit against HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius over the 2010 Physician Fee Schedule.
Read more
ACC Statement on Health Care Reform
The ACC used the State of the Union address to highlight the need to reverse the Medicare cuts.
Read more
Medicare Patients and Physicians Join Petition Drive
Patients and physicians in Washington, DC joined a petition drive calling on Congress for Medicare reform.
Read moreMedicare Payment Rates Across Cardiology And Other Specialties
Medicare physician payment is often discussed as if each specialty receives a single hourly or annual rate. In reality, Medicare pays for individual services under the Physician Fee Schedule. The amount depends on the work involved, clinical expenses, malpractice costs, geographic location, and whether the service is performed in a hospital or office.
Cardiology illustrates why broad comparisons can be misleading. A routine office follow-up, electrocardiogram, echocardiogram, cardiac catheterization, and stent procedure each carry a different payment. Some services are brief but technically demanding, while others involve extensive preparation, equipment, monitoring, and follow-up care.
Comparing cardiology reimbursement with payments to primary care, dermatology, orthopedics, neurology, and other fields still reveals important policy differences. It also shows why across-the-board Medicare cuts can affect patient access even when a specialty appears to receive higher payments for selected procedures.
How Medicare Physician Payment Works
The Medicare Physician Fee Schedule assigns relative value units, commonly called RVUs, to covered services. Work RVUs reflect physician time, technical skill, mental effort, and clinical judgment. Practice expense RVUs account for staff, equipment, supplies, and office overhead. Malpractice RVUs cover professional liability costs.
The total RVUs are adjusted by geographic practice cost indices and multiplied by a national conversion factor. Congress and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services can change that conversion factor, modify evaluation and management rules, or revise individual procedure values. A payment reduction can therefore affect many services at once.
The facility where care occurs also matters. A physician may receive a professional payment for a hospital-based procedure, while the hospital bills separately for the facility component. Office-based services generally include more practice expense in the physician payment. Comparing a hospital procedure with an office visit without separating these components can produce an inaccurate picture.
Why Cardiology Can Look Better Paid
Cardiology includes a substantial number of diagnostic and procedural services. Echocardiography, stress testing, rhythm monitoring, catheterization, electrophysiology, and interventional procedures require specialized training and equipment. Their Medicare payments often exceed the payment for a standard office visit because they carry additional work and practice costs.
That does not mean every cardiology encounter is highly reimbursed. A cardiologist may spend considerable time reviewing records, interpreting tests, coordinating medications, communicating with other clinicians, and managing chronic conditions. Some of that work is bundled into a procedure payment or is difficult to capture through conventional billing codes.
Cardiology practices also face high fixed expenses. Imaging systems, laboratory equipment, cardiac monitoring technology, trained technicians, accreditation, maintenance, and compliance requirements can cost substantial amounts. A larger payment for an echocardiogram or intervention may therefore represent the resources required to deliver the service rather than excess income.
Illustrative Payments Across Specialties
The figures below are broad, approximate professional payment ranges based on common Medicare Physician Fee Schedule services before patient-specific adjustments. They are intended to show relative patterns, not establish a universal rate. Actual amounts vary by CPT code, locality, modifiers, facility status, annual rule changes, and whether technical and professional components are billed separately.
| Specialty and Representative Service | Approximate Professional Payment Range | Main Payment Drivers | Common Access Concern |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cardiology office follow-up | $90–$150 | Visit complexity, medical decision-making, time | Pressure on time for chronic disease management |
| Cardiology ECG or rhythm interpretation | $10–$35 | Interpretation and technical component rules | Low payment may discourage testing in small practices |
| Cardiology echocardiography | $75–$125 | Physician interpretation, equipment, staff, facility status | Equipment and staffing costs can outpace reimbursement |
| Cardiac catheterization or intervention | $250–$1,100+ | Procedural intensity, global rules, facility setting | Volume and overhead do not eliminate payment reductions |
| Primary care complex office visit | $100–$180 | Complexity, time, care coordination | Rising workload and limited appointment capacity |
| Dermatology biopsy or minor procedure | $35–$175 | Procedure work, supplies, pathology arrangements | Lower-priced procedures can be difficult in high-cost areas |
| Orthopedic injection or surgery | $75–$1,200+ | Procedure complexity and global surgical period | Bundled payments may cover weeks of follow-up |
| Neurology consultation or diagnostic testing | $100–$300 | Cognitive work, interpretation, technical resources | Time-intensive evaluation may be undervalued |
A higher professional payment for a cardiac intervention does not automatically mean cardiology is paid more fairly across its full range of work. A procedure may include preoperative assessment, the intervention itself, immediate recovery management, and postoperative care under a global payment. If a fee schedule reduction applies to the bundle, the effect can extend beyond the time spent in the procedure room.
By contrast, some specialties rely heavily on evaluation and management services. Primary care and cognitive specialties may receive lower payment per encounter while handling large panels of patients, extensive documentation, medication management, and coordination with multiple providers. The relevant comparison is the relationship between payment and the resources required to provide safe care.
The Role Of Global And Bundled Payments
Medicare uses global surgical periods for many procedures. A single payment can cover the procedure and defined follow-up services for a specified period. This arrangement is intended to promote efficient care, but it can make a procedure's headline payment appear larger than the amount available for each individual encounter.
Cardiology includes both global and separately billable services. An interventional cardiologist may receive payment for a procedure that includes considerable technical risk, while a general cardiologist may spend repeated visits managing heart failure, coronary disease, arrhythmia, or hypertension. The mix of services differs widely between practices.
Bundling also affects comparisons with orthopedics, ophthalmology, vascular surgery, and other procedural specialties. A payment should be evaluated alongside the number of visits included, the cost of supplies, staffing requirements, complication risk, and the duration of follow-up responsibility. Looking at a single code cannot answer whether a specialty is adequately reimbursed.
Why Payment Cuts Affect Patient Access
Medicare payment reductions can place pressure on practices that serve a large share of older adults and people with disabilities. When reimbursement declines while wages, rent, technology, insurance, and regulatory costs rise, practices may respond by limiting new Medicare appointments, postponing equipment purchases, consolidating with larger systems, or reducing services in rural and underserved locations.
Cardiology access is particularly sensitive to delays. Symptoms such as chest discomfort, shortness of breath, fainting, and irregular heartbeat may require prompt evaluation. Delayed diagnostic testing can lead to emergency department visits, avoidable hospitalizations, or progression of untreated disease.
The effect is not uniform. A large health system may absorb a reduction differently from an independent cardiology group. Urban areas may have multiple competing practices, while rural communities may depend on one local cardiologist or visiting specialist. A national payment policy can therefore create very different local consequences.
Reading Specialty Comparisons Carefully
Payment per service is different from physician income. Income reflects payer mix, practice expenses, staff costs, procedure volume, call obligations, uncompensated care, and time spent on activities that may not generate a separate bill. Medicare rates are also distinct from commercial insurance contracts, which can use different fee schedules and negotiating methods.
The Medicare conversion factor is another important context. When it falls, the reduction can affect primary care, cardiology, surgery, and other specialties simultaneously. Even when relative values are rebalanced to favor evaluation and management services, a practice may still experience a decline if its service mix includes technical procedures, imaging, or bundled care.
A balanced assessment should therefore examine several measures: payment per service, payment per hour, total practice cost, patient complexity, follow-up obligations, and access in the communities served. This broader view supports better policy decisions than ranking specialties by a handful of procedure prices.
Priorities For A Fairer Payment Policy
- Preserve adequate payment for complex cardiovascular evaluation, chronic disease management, and diagnostic interpretation.
- Account for staffing, equipment, malpractice, technology, and geographic costs when updating relative values.
- Protect independent and rural practices that have fewer options to offset Medicare fee schedule reductions.
- Evaluate global procedure payments alongside required follow-up care and patient management.
- Use access data, appointment availability, and service closures to measure the real effect of payment changes.
Preserving Access To Cardiovascular Care
A meaningful comparison of Medicare reimbursement must connect payment policy with the care patients actually receive. Cardiology may include several relatively well-paid procedures, yet its practices also carry substantial infrastructure costs and provide large amounts of cognitive, coordination, and follow-up work. Other specialties face their own combinations of low payment, high volume, bundled obligations, and rising overhead.
Patients and physicians can help make those effects visible. Share experiences with delayed appointments, reduced services, or difficulty maintaining cardiovascular care through the Campaign for Patient Access. Support public education and legislative advocacy that encourage Medicare policies capable of sustaining qualified clinicians, functioning practices, and timely heart care.
Campaign for Patient Access