About the Campaign
The Campaign for Patient Access was launched by the American College of Cardiology in December 2009 as a national effort to reverse Medicare physician fee schedule cuts that threatened cardiovascular care. The site provided background on the issue, the ACC's legislative and legal response, resources for patients and practices, a newsroom tracking coverage across the country, and ways for supporters to share their stories and support the campaign.
From the Newsroom
Medicare Meltdown: Access to Health Care in "Critical Condition"
A press release warning that cardiology access was in critical condition due to Medicare payment cuts.
Read more
Cardiology Takes Legal Action Against Medicare
The ACC filed suit against HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius over the 2010 Physician Fee Schedule.
Read more
ACC Statement on Health Care Reform
The ACC used the State of the Union address to highlight the need to reverse the Medicare cuts.
Read more
Medicare Patients and Physicians Join Petition Drive
Patients and physicians in Washington, DC joined a petition drive calling on Congress for Medicare reform.
Read moreHow Medicare Payment Policy Put Cardiology Access at Risk
Medicare physician payment policy can look like a technical exercise involving conversion factors, relative value units, and budget neutrality. For cardiologists and patients, however, each annual adjustment can influence appointment availability, diagnostic services, staffing, and the financial stability of practices that provide essential cardiovascular care.
The pressure has accumulated over several years. Proposed Medicare cuts to cardiology have often emerged through the Physician Fee Schedule, where increases for some services must be balanced by reductions elsewhere. Even when Congress or federal agencies later soften a reduction, the uncertainty can make it harder for practices to plan and maintain access.
A timeline of proposed Medicare cuts to cardiology shows how separate rulemaking decisions became part of a continuing access concern. It also explains why physicians, patients, and professional organizations have urged policymakers to examine the effects of payment changes on real communities rather than viewing each percentage change in isolation.
Why The Physician Fee Schedule Matters
The Medicare Physician Fee Schedule determines payment for thousands of services, including office visits, imaging-related work, catheter-based procedures, testing, and care coordination. The system assigns relative value units to services and applies a conversion factor to translate those values into payment amounts. Geographic adjustments and other formulas affect the final amount.
Budget neutrality is a central feature of the system. When the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services increases the value of selected services, it generally must offset that increase by reducing the conversion factor or lowering payments elsewhere. A policy intended to recognize the complexity of evaluation and management care can therefore create substantial pressure on procedural and specialty services.
Cardiology practices are particularly sensitive to these changes because they combine office-based care, hospital coordination, diagnostic testing, chronic disease management, and procedures. A reduction in professional payment may affect whether a practice can hire nurses, maintain care coordinators, invest in equipment, or continue serving patients in rural and underserved areas.
The Early Warning Signs
The modern timeline begins with the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015, commonly known as MACRA. The law repealed the Sustainable Growth Rate formula and created new payment pathways, including the Quality Payment Program. Although MACRA was designed to reward quality and value, it also introduced reporting requirements and new financial uncertainty for physicians.
During the late 2010s, Medicare payment updates remained modest while practice expenses continued to rise. Cardiologists faced growing demands related to electronic health records, prior authorization, quality reporting, cybersecurity, and workforce recruitment. These costs did not always appear in the headline payment calculations.
A major turning point came with the 2020 Physician Fee Schedule rule. CMS increased the relative value assigned to several office and outpatient evaluation and management services. Because of budget neutrality, the change produced a significant reduction in the conversion factor for 2021. The policy was intended to better recognize cognitive and coordinated care, but its financing mechanism shifted the burden toward many specialties that deliver procedures and diagnostic services.
The 2021 Shock And Temporary Relief
For 2021, the conversion factor fell by roughly 10.4 percent before later congressional action. The reduction was unusually visible because it arrived during the COVID-19 pandemic, when medical practices were already dealing with postponed care, supply expenses, staffing shortages, and unpredictable patient volume.
Cardiology groups warned that the payment change could threaten the viability of services patients rely on to diagnose and manage heart disease. Reductions in professional reimbursement do not necessarily mean that a patient’s total cost falls. Instead, they can affect whether physicians accept Medicare patients, how quickly appointments are available, and whether practices can sustain less profitable services.
Congress ultimately provided temporary relief through legislation that delayed or offset part of the 2021 reduction. Additional short-term measures followed in subsequent years. These interventions reduced the immediate damage but did not resolve the underlying structure: annual updates, budget neutrality, and inflationary pressures could continue to produce downward payment adjustments.
The cardiologist’s perspective helps connect these policy mechanics to clinical realities, including the resources required to provide timely cardiovascular care.
A Pattern Of Annual Reductions
The 2022 rule brought another difficult adjustment. After temporary relief, the conversion factor again faced a decrease, although Congress added a short-term positive payment update to moderate the effect. The cycle illustrated the difference between a permanent policy solution and a temporary legislative patch. Practices could avoid the full reduction for a year, but long-term planning remained difficult.
In 2023, CMS proposed a conversion factor decrease of approximately 4.4 percent, and the final rule produced a reduction of about 4.5 percent before later legislative adjustments. The change reflected updates to relative values and budget-neutrality requirements. For cardiology, the effect depended on each practice’s service mix, payer distribution, staffing model, and location.
The 2024 proposed rule continued the pattern, with CMS initially projecting a conversion factor decrease of about 3.36 percent. The final rule set a reduction of roughly 3.4 percent. Temporary congressional relief again moderated the effect, but the basic concern remained: practices could face nominal payment cuts at the same time that wages, rent, technology, medical supplies, and compliance expenses increased.
| Policy year | Major development | Potential effect on cardiovascular care |
|---|---|---|
| 2015 | MACRA replaced the Sustainable Growth Rate approach | New quality programs and reporting obligations increased administrative complexity |
| 2020 rule for 2021 | Office visit valuation increased, triggering budget-neutrality pressure | Conversion factor reduction placed greater pressure on procedural specialties |
| 2022 | Temporary legislative payment relief followed another scheduled decrease | Short-term protection helped practices but left future reductions uncertain |
| 2023 | CMS proposed and finalized another reduction in the conversion factor | Cardiology groups faced renewed pressure on staffing and service capacity |
| 2024 | Another proposed and finalized decrease was partly moderated by Congress | Repeated temporary fixes failed to create predictable payment growth |
| 2025 | CMS issued another negative conversion factor update | Practices continued to plan around unstable Medicare reimbursement |
Why The Impact Extends Beyond Reimbursement
A Medicare physician payment cut can affect access through several connected channels. When revenue declines, a practice may delay replacing diagnostic equipment, reduce clinic hours, limit new patient appointments, or consolidate locations. These decisions are especially consequential in communities where there are few cardiologists and long travel distances to hospitals.
Payment reductions can also alter the balance between different types of care. A practice may have greater difficulty supporting follow-up visits, preventive counseling, remote monitoring, or care coordination when those services do not cover their staffing costs. Patients with heart failure, coronary artery disease, arrhythmias, and multiple chronic conditions often need sustained management rather than a single procedure.
The effects are not identical everywhere. Large health systems may absorb changes differently from independent practices. Urban and rural markets have different workforce conditions, while academic centers, community cardiology groups, and subspecialty practices may have distinct cost structures. This is why a national percentage cannot fully describe the access consequences.
The issue also involves timing. Patients whose appointments are postponed may present later with more advanced disease, emergency symptoms, or avoidable hospitalizations. A payment policy that appears modest in a federal budget can therefore create broader costs for families, hospitals, employers, and the Medicare program.
Reading Proposed Cuts Carefully
A proposed rule is not the same as a final rule, and a final rule is not always the final amount a physician receives. CMS publishes a proposal, accepts public comments, issues a final rule, and may then be affected by legislation or administrative action. The conversion factor is only one component of the calculation, and individual services can move in different directions.
Stakeholders should distinguish among the proposed percentage, the final agency decision, and any congressional adjustment. They should also examine whether a change is temporary or permanent. A one-year increase may provide immediate help without addressing the structural formula that creates repeated reductions in later years.
Another important distinction is between payment rates and practice costs. Even if a statutory patch prevents a nominal cut, reimbursement may still fail to keep pace with inflation. A flat payment in a high-cost labor market can function like a real reduction, particularly for practices that depend heavily on Medicare beneficiaries.
Following the complete rulemaking record makes advocacy more credible. Physicians can document appointment delays, equipment decisions, workforce shortages, and uncompensated care. Patients can describe travel burdens, difficulty finding a specialist, or disruptions in ongoing treatment. These stories give policymakers evidence that complements actuarial estimates.
What Stakeholders Can Do
Effective advocacy should connect policy language with specific access outcomes. A clear record helps legislators and regulators understand why stable Medicare reimbursement matters to patients with cardiovascular disease.
- Track annual CMS Physician Fee Schedule proposals, final rules, and congressional payment updates.
- Share concrete examples of delayed appointments, reduced services, staffing pressures, or clinic closures.
- Explain how cardiovascular care depends on follow-up visits, testing, prevention, and coordination as well as procedures.
- Encourage professional societies, medical practices, and patient groups to present consistent evidence about local access.
- Ask policymakers to evaluate inflation, workforce costs, and rural access when designing physician payment reforms.
Physicians can also communicate the operational consequences of payment policy without relying on technical jargon. A statement that a cut may eliminate a nurse-led heart failure program or extend appointment waits is more meaningful to many audiences than a reference to a relative value unit alone.
Patients have an important role in this process because access problems are experienced directly. Personal accounts can show how a shortage of cardiologists affects transportation, employment, medication management, and family caregiving. When those experiences are combined with practice-level data, they create a stronger case for predictable and adequate Medicare payments.
Building A More Stable Path Forward
The recurring timeline suggests that temporary payment patches cannot substitute for durable reform. Policymakers can consider approaches that recognize inflation, reduce unnecessary administrative burden, protect essential services, and evaluate the effect of budget neutrality across specialties. Any change should preserve incentives for high-quality care without weakening the physician workforce that delivers it.
A sustainable approach should also measure access directly. Payment policy should be evaluated through indicators such as appointment availability, geographic distribution of cardiologists, participation in Medicare, preventive care capacity, and the ability to maintain diagnostic and chronic care services. These measures would reveal consequences that a national conversion factor alone can miss.
Cardiovascular disease remains a major cause of illness and death, and patients depend on timely specialist care at every stage. The record of proposed Medicare cuts shows why payment decisions deserve public attention before a rule takes effect. Patients and physicians can help shape that record by sharing their experiences and supporting advocacy for reliable access to cardiology services.agext
Campaign for Patient Access